Melanchthonian Discourse: Reconstructing the Intellectual Ecosystem of Reformation Humanism

Tomás Antonio Valle (PhD University of Notre Dame, 2023): 'Melanchthonian Discourse: Reconstructing the Intellectual Ecosystem of Reformation Humanism'

Humanism and Protestantism form a central part of the classic, textbook narrative of Western and world civilization. Both “-isms” transformed the culture and intellectual life of northern Europe almost simultaneously, progressing from embattled beginnings in the first decades of the sixteenth century to lasting institutional establishment by 1600. While scholars agree that these phenomena intertwined with each other, the precise character of their mutual influence remains unclear and debated. My current project investigates this key historical nexus: it seeks to unravel both how religious concerns and controversies shaped developments in sixteenth-century learning and, conversely, how humanist practices of reading, writing, and teaching fueled conflicting trends within the religious cultures of the day.

To do so, my research reconstructs the intellectual culture that most influentially combined humanist scholarship and teaching with evangelical belief and devotion: Wittenberg University in the mid-1500s. At this culture’s center stood Philipp Melanchthon, a prodigy of classical erudition and Protestantism’s first systematic theologian. Triangulating Melanchthon’s prolific publications and annotated books with a broad swathe of print and manuscript material produced by his colleagues and students provides fine-grained insights into the production and transfer of evangelical, humanist knowledge. Key to this approach is a novel methodology that analyzes intellectual culture and change-over-time not in terms of disciplines or seminal texts but via smaller elements such as quotations, terms, metaphors, and textual authorities—components of a larger ecosystem of learning, but with individual “life cycles” of development, circulation, and transformation.

This lecture will outline the project’s aims, sources, and methodology, as well as some early findings.

Tomás Antonio Valle (PhD University of Notre Dame, 2023) specializes in the learned world of late humanism in Lutheran German territories and has spent over two years researching at the Herzog August Bibliothek and the Forschungszentrum Gotha, among other institutions, with funding from the Fulbright Commission and the DAAD. His most recent journal article argues for a re-evaluation of Lutheran intellectual culture: “Eilhard Lubin, Academic Unorthodoxy, and the Dynamics of Confessional Intellectual Cultures,” in Journal of the History of Ideas (2022). As of October 2023, he has begun a three-year “Excellence Strategy” postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Hamburg, investigating the production and transfer of knowledge at sixteenth-century Wittenberg.

ATTENDANCE FREE IN PERSON OR ONLINE WITH ADVANCE BOOKING

image: detail - Lukas Cranach the Younger: miniature of Philipp Melanchthon in a vellum Bible printed at Wittenberg, 1560, now held at the Bayerische Staatsbibliothek in Munich. Image taken from plate 5 of Hans-Peter Hasse, "Melanchthon und die 'Alba amicorum': Melanchthons Theologie im Spiegel seiner Bucheintragungen," in Der Theologe Melanchthon, edited by Günter Frank (Stuttgart: Thorbecke, 2000), 291–338.